This chapter is a great example of the advantages of having letters rather than sermons collected in the bible. For me this is about the risks and rewards of being brutal with other Christians. And we’ve all had these moments in Christian relationships where things get cathartic.
Paul is talking to a subset of the Corinthians. Last chapter he’s told them not to be yoked with unbelievers, and follows it up here with encouragement to purify themselves to claim the promises he mentions in the last chapter, which are all about group purity.
So I think the purifying is not personal, purifying your heart, as much as corporate, purifying your group. Ignoring a few bad apples in the congregation who are clearly not even Christians.
This subset Paul is trusting to address here is far more praiseworthy than the church as whole from chapter one, which clearly had big problems.
But he’s still in this super awkward place of having hurt them with his missing letter, the brutal one where he told them all the ways they were pathetic.
Titus is the link here, because he has visited them since the mean letter, and now he is with Paul. And he’s reported that for this large chunk of the church they took it just the right way. They heard Gods voice, not just Paul in it. They repented.
It’s very risky pointing out to someone spiritual flaws which have hurt you personally. Trying to both teacher/truth telling prophet AND hurt puppy who needs more love.
And Paul was in struggle street in Macedonia when Titus arrived from his visit to the Corinthians. I loved his pithy summary of how badly it was going “harassed at every turn, conflicts on the outside, fears within”.
So the report that the letter has been taken in the right spirit filled Paul with joy and encouragement. He is so happy with the core of Corinthians who saw God, and accepted god’s voice, past the personal conflict.
You wouldn’t get all that from a sermon. I’ve know lots of people who have a hesitancy towards st Paul. I do too, like yesterday when I was thinking he was a bit much. But I suppose that partly reflects this exposed awkward relational dynamic. Other than Acts, we only know him though letters.
But it’s grace-building stuff, this struggle. It’s like the church’s super power. I know the grace that come from the risk of being real, it is wonderful!
Lockdown has given me, and many others I’m sure, permission to avoid a lot of that conflict for a while. But I’ve been swept over by an ennui that has come from avoiding this risk. Yesterday I caught up with Colin from church, who has been actually more active than me, but admitted to just letting some things slide himself, too.
So be risky, be real, tell your story even if you seem pathetic or demanding. Paul talks about godly sorrow verses worldly sorrow here. His letter caused godly sorrow, and he’s so relieved. And comforted in a tough time.
you became sorrowful as God intended and so were not harmed in any way by us. … See what this godly sorrow has produced in you: what earnestness, what eagerness to clear yourselves, what indignation, what alarm, what longing, what concern, what readiness to see justice done.
V 9 and 11
Be brave. Maybe that’s a title for a song about Corinthians 2. Lockdown is easing a little as vaccination rates increase. Our youth group will restart Friday week. Back into the fray, with this word to inspire me!
Also Kelly’s birthday today, but maybe this is NOT a moment for brutality. She’s very down, and I’m hopeless at birthdays. Praying for some simple silly joy!